Fox News Art Critics So Mad Official Obama Portraits Are Pictures Of Black People
They're so divisive. (And gorgeous)
The official portraits of Barack and Michelle Obama were unveiled at the National Portrait Gallery, and by god we like 'em. Some people are griping because they aren't photorealistic depictions of Barry and Michelle, but that's exactly what we like about them. Kehinde Wiley's painting of President Obama actually puts him in a fairly traditional, if somewhat casual pose, no tie, but sitting in a chair looking like he's thinking of ... destroying America probably, or perhaps trying to figure out how he's going to save it, more like. Or maybe he's trying to recall the name of the bad guy in a Conan the Barbarian comic. He really is such a nerd.
Oh, but all that greenery! This is the president in a garden (or, strangely, hovering in one?), a president whose first lady was famous for her garden at the White House. Put him in the garden, then, in a green place that's as lush as his native Hawaii. We won't Freshman Art it to death, but damn, it's nice.
The New York Times artsplains:
From the greenery sprout flowers that have symbolic meaning for the sitter. African blue lilies represent Kenya, his father’s birthplace; jasmine stands for Hawaii, where Mr. Obama himself was born; chrysanthemums, the official flower of Chicago, reference the city where his political career began, and where he met his wife.
We loved this tweet, too:
And then there's Amy Sherald’s portrait of Michelle Obama, which at first seems muted, but then you start noticing the colors in the dress (a design by Michelle Smith, the NYT informs us couture dolts) and that pose that's as serious as a presidential portrait. More artsplaining:
Ms. Sherald also starts with realism, but softens and abstracts it. She gives all her figures gray-toned skin — a color with ambiguous racial associations — and reduces bodies to geometric forms silhouetted against single-color fields.
Yr Editrix, who IS an art critic, had this to say:
They're both gorgeous paintings, and we don't mind saying half of that is because we're taken by their subjects.
Not everybody loved 'em. Fox News had a little difficulty settling on a headline for its story. Originally (we love the Wayback Machine) it was "Michelle Obama portrait faces social media mockery after unveiling." That actually got meaner after a while, morphing into "Michelle Obama portrait faces brutal mockery after unveiling." Apparently that was TOO mean, since, as of right now, it's "Michelle Obama portrait faces brutal mockery, some praise after unveiling." Isn't that nice of them? The piece noted that several people on Twitter insisted it wasn't even really a painting of Michelle Obama, possibly because they only remember her from Twitter memes and Ben Garrison cartoons as a screaming harpy shoveling junk food in her face while making YOUR kids eat cardboard.
Ben Shapiro was classy as ever:
To be fair, the Fox piece also included some people who really liked the portraits, plus some from Obama fans who thought Michelle might not have liked the portrait, which strikes us as nuts.
Noted aesthete Rush Limbaugh was thoroughly disgusted by the paintings and by liberals' reactions to them, because like a bunch of sheeple we're all saying we like them because we like the Obamas:
The conservative host zeroed in on CNN and “some guy named Fallon” — former Hillary Clinton campaign spokesman Brian Fallon. Limbaugh claimed that Fallon stopped just short of crying. And in a highly mocking tone, the host mimicked the Clinton staffer’s remarks.
“Oh my God this is so wonderful!” A highly sarcastic Limbaugh said. “To have braininess back. To have intelligence, to have people we could be proud of!”
By way of counterpoint, Rush Limbaugh is a fucking idiot.
One more and we're out:
They are just saying, racist white people, THEY ARE JUST SAYING!
It's now your OPEN THREAD! Talk about art if you want! Or about something else! You know how this works.
Update: We would be remiss if we failed to include this essential Chicago perspective from Chris Hayes:
Doktor Zoom's real name is Marty Kelley, and he lives in the wilds of Boise, Idaho. He is not a medical doctor, but does have a real PhD in Rhetoric. You should definitely donate some money to this little mommyblog where he has finally found acceptance and cat pictures. He is on maternity leave until 2033. Here is his Twitter, also. His quest to avoid prolixity is not going so great.