Discussion about this post

User's avatar
swmnguy's avatar

This is good. There, I said it and I feel better.

I can't see it without an eventual eyeroll and "FFS" under my breath.

These people are here. They're working. Our economy absolutely depends on their labor. They and their families, net/net, pay in far more to the US government and overall economy than a lot of us who are here lawfully. Our laws are arbitrary and stupid, and always have been. The Southern border cannot be secured. We put it right in between where people live and where they have to work; and it's too long and too rugged unless we put our entire military on that border. Which would probably be better for our national security than having them all over the world, especially in places where they aren't wanted; but still idiotic.

Nobody has ever been able to explain to me what the actual problem is, that couldn't be solved by just giving everyone who wants a job a Social Security number and forcing employers to not steal their tax withholding.

Unless and until we start jailing CEOs for employing people unlawfully, we're not serious. So, if we're not serious, at least we shouldn't break up families and waste untold resources making people miserable when all they want to do is work and take care of their families.

So yeah. This is good. But Jeez. What, we want a medal for doing less of stupid shit?

Expand full comment
Brando's avatar

Biden's policy on immigration, while it seems to confuse a lot of his detractors, is rather exactly where the median American is on this issue--increase legal immigration, strict enforcement of border crossings to crack down on illegal immigration, and implement this in an efficient and humane way so as not to break up families or punish children who are crossing now or who came here long ago.

It'd be nice if we had a functioning Congress that could pass legislation enabling this, but short of that it will mean doing as much of this as possible through executive action.

Remember the alternative under Trump--inefficient enforcement spackled with random cruelty under the leadership of people who have no idea what the fuck they're doing, and Stephen "Those Dead Nurses Were in My Trunk When I Bought the Car" Miller.

Expand full comment
201 more comments...

No posts