284 Comments
User's avatar
Marla's avatar

Silly me. And I thought the Supremacy clause meant that Federal law overrode any local laws. EMTALA is a federal law, is it not?

And a hearty fuck you goes out to Ken Paxton from out here in not so sunny SoCal.

Expand full comment
2Cats2Furious's avatar

Because the header photo is of my Babby Axl - who is now hale and hearty - I’m going to re-post a version of a response I made below:

Alone. Abandoned. Afraid.

Yet, this 3 week-old kitten in Texas was able to get the lifesaving healthcare he needed.

Don’t Texas women deserve at least as much?

Expand full comment
Zyxomma's avatar

Ta, Dok. If you value your life and the lives of the people you love, vote a straight Democratic ticket, every election, every year.

Expand full comment
2Cats2Furious's avatar

Just FYI, Texas got rid of straight-ballot voting, I believe after the 2008 election (when most of our major cities turned blue).

When I voted in 2022, I had to vote for 101 different candidates (mostly judges) and propositions/bond issues. Which meant hitting the screen over 200 times (once to vote for a candidate, and then to click next. Voter suppression - in all its forms - is a very real thing.

Expand full comment
beb's avatar

It's become increasingly evident that the Fifth District Court of Appeal as well as the State of Texas should be abolished.

Expand full comment
Ethereal Fairy's avatar

The fifth circuit court should be aborted.

Expand full comment
Tosca's avatar

Fucking madness.

I sincerely hope Kate Cox never returns to that shithole, because they'll throw her in jail.

Expand full comment
Fiddlesticks's avatar

Chilling. Texas deserves so much better.

Expand full comment
Judge Mental's avatar

Texas women deserve better. Texas needs a quick kick to the naughty bits.

Expand full comment
Enbastet's avatar

EMTALA is not a treatment statute - it is an anti-dumping statute. It was created to prevent turfing people to the street in an unstable condition after a bad wallet biopsy.

If a doctor believes that an abortion is needed for stabilization they are still dangling out there because the state will show up with "experts" to say that it wasn't - that more antibiotics or transfusions would have "stabilized" the sepsis or bleeding.

The lawsuit currently chugging along to have courts enshrine "best medical judgment" is equally useless for the same reason.

"The battle of the experts" is one thing in medmal litigation where all that is at stake is money, but in these states the doctor's freedom is on the line, up to a life sentence, and no law can correct for the fact that abortion is presumed to be illegal, making any exception narrow and hard to apply.

The best advice that I can give to these doctors as an MD/JD is to leave...

Expand full comment
Megan Macomber's avatar

James Ho and the Ho Hos strike again. Wouldn't want to cause ER docs the "aesthetic displeasure" of saving a woman's life--that's just gross.

The Fifth Circuit is obscene.

Expand full comment
Sky 777's avatar

I hear from medical colleagues in red states that they are being heavily recruited by practices and hospitals in blue states. Most I know are considering leaving, especially ER docs and the ON/Gyns.

It is simple:

National shortage of physicians means openings in blue states.

Blue states are not coming after your license/livelihood/freedom.

Many are quietly relocating.

Expand full comment
Rynlikesit's avatar

I am a medical professional with over 15 years experience in an emergency department and I can tell you I would never, not in a million years, work in an institution, or state, that told me I couldn’t save a patients life that could be saved. It is monstrously unethical and I can assure you they will bleed practitioners, and when they do, they will sit around scratching their heads and wonder what went wrong.

Expand full comment
Zyxomma's avatar

Thank you. I'm a Care Coordinator for HIV positive adults in a federally qualified health center. I just finished a course (for certification) from IHI on quality improvement in healthcare, and most of it centers on patient safety. How are patients ever to be safe if they can't access lifesaving treatment?

Expand full comment
SethTriggs's avatar

This is what happens when Republican christofascists pick judges. Punish these fascists and vote them out of office this fall. Your mission is the same as we succeeded in 2020 and 2022, outnumber the fascists and their supporters at the polls.

Expand full comment
Dorothea is a Democrat's avatar

I think Babby Axle was perhaps the cutest kitten I have ever seen. That is all.

Expand full comment
2Cats2Furious's avatar

🥰

Expand full comment
Seek's avatar

Just cut off their federal funding. I understand from a certain former dude that whatever the President does is legal so make it so Dark Brandon. Of course I'm being facetious but Jesus Fucking Christ all of these dipshits in TX who don't vote kinda deserve this nonsense. The demographics say this is a blue state if people would register and turn out. They don't so it's gerrymandered to hell and back but ... Gahhhhhhhhhh

Expand full comment
Crystalclear12's avatar

Ken Paxton deserves a special hell.

Expand full comment
TheGreatAndPowerfulMormos!'s avatar

EVERY WOMAN IN TEXAS SHOULD GO ON STRIKE UNTIL THEIR BASIC FUCKING HUMANITY IS RESTORED.

Expand full comment
Wondering Woman's avatar

Except that it would probably incite more violence in a state that allows any asshole with a pulse to buy a gun.

Expand full comment
Davis's avatar

If I remember correctly, women in ancient Greece refused sex until the men stopped fighting.

Expand full comment
meh's avatar

Lysistrata.

I wonder if it would work today....

Expand full comment
Ethereal Fairy's avatar

It was a comedy, because it only punishes the men that respect women's right to say no. Rapists don't do "consent".

Expand full comment
Davis's avatar

Thank you. I forgot her name.

Expand full comment
TheGreatAndPowerfulMormos!'s avatar

Fucking ghouls

Expand full comment