316 Comments
User's avatar
skinnercitycyclist's avatar

"teaching rebellion of school board authority"

I tell my students, especially ones that are less keen on education, that there are two types of authority: official and actual. As a teacher, I have official authority based on. the state having placed me in the classroom with certain responsibilities. The actual is that I am educated, and know some things that those students need to know to pass high school (short-term) and in life (long-term). They can quibble all they want about the former, and I do not care about it that much, but if they want an education they should at least respect and engage with the latter.

Expand full comment
beb's avatar

Did they also ban "Fahrenheit 451" or "1984" both very subversive books about authoritarianism.

Expand full comment
skinnercitycyclist's avatar

Whether they did or not, both are often banned.

Expand full comment
John Glocke's avatar

I keep saying that any writings that encourage citizens to disobey authority are downright Unamerican, but they still won't ban that foul Declaration against the authority of King George.

Expand full comment
skinnercitycyclist's avatar

Didn't they try it in 1861?

Expand full comment
BlueSpot's avatar

"the first step toward majoring in English Literature, Women’s Studies, or Anarchist Bombmaking."

Doktor Zoom is reading my notes for my substack. : )

Expand full comment
Zyxomma's avatar

Ta, Dok. Way too many firemen of the Fahrenheit 451 variety.

Expand full comment
Pixeloid's avatar

No matter how rotten authoritarian, bigoted, white "Christian" nationalist/supremacist fascists become, every day they give us even MORE reasons to hate them.

Expand full comment
marydn's avatar

Apparently my Roman Catholic, Republican, Conservative parents were radicals and I never knew because they let me read "From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler". Actually they let me read whatever I wanted so definitely radicals. By the way you know who else banned books and didn't like it when their authority was disrespected? The Nazis. Yeah, I went there. If it fits, it fits.

Expand full comment
Stosh Wychulus's avatar

opps......just found the donation link and will promptly do that. Good idea to make that clearer.

Expand full comment
Stosh Wychulus's avatar

Hey, where's you make a one time donation link? Lots of us would make a donation who can't do all the upgrade to paid option.

Expand full comment
Manic Pixel Dream Girl's avatar

“It doesn’t teach kids to respect authoriteh, and that causes unrest …” Can’t have that. They might grow up and storm the seat of government … Oh, wait … 🤔

Expand full comment
Goldfish's avatar

I hereby volunteer to buy this book for a kid.

Expand full comment
Zen Gali's avatar

“Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right.”

Expand full comment
Darth Trad's avatar

Every fucking book in America that discusses the refusal of British Americans to accept the authority of George III and to come out in open rebellion against him and his agents MUST BE BANNED NOW!!! What example does it show the children of today? That disobedience and concerted disrespect for authority is acceptable? Remove them all now!

Expand full comment
Lefty Wright's avatar

I seem to recall Trump defending a lot of MAGA cultists against illegal actions they commit simply because they disagree with what Congress is getting ready to do on 1/6. In fact he calls them hostages and heroes. I bet Trump would call Amy Anne a hero and the book a hostage. Don't you? If Trump is anything he's fair and honest, right?

Expand full comment
Darth Trad's avatar

'Come back to see me when you're a 10 honey'

Expand full comment
Manic Pixel Dream Girl's avatar

I read that as “come see me when you’re 10” and didn’t think it was an entirely unfair character aspersion.

Expand full comment
Darrell Leland's avatar

FLASH! BOOK BANNERS BAN BOOK ABOUT BOOK BANNERS BANNING BOOKS! FILM AT 1100!

Expand full comment