Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Doktor Zoom's avatar

Crom help me, out of curiosity, I asked ChatGPT to write a fifth-grade level book report on a Charles Dickens novel about whaling that doesn't exist, and to make it very clear the student made it up and is a very bad liar.

***

"Book Report: The Whales of Wetherby by Charles Dickens

By: Jason M. (5th Grade)

So I read a book called The Whales of Wetherby by Charles Dickens. You probably haven’t heard of it because it’s super rare and not in the library for some reason. But I definitely read it. It’s totally a real book.

This book takes place in, like, old England times, but also mostly on a boat. The main character is a boy named Edward or Edwin (it changes sometimes) and he wants to go whaling because his dad disappeared during a whale attack. This is a very common thing in Dickens books, I think.

He sneaks onto a whaling ship called the Whale Boat Extreme—or maybe it was The Ice Dragon—and meets a bunch of whalers with strange names like Captain Mustache and Old Salty Dave. They speak in fancy old words like “thou whale beast!” and “yo ho, melancholy.” I think that’s how people talked back then.

There are a lot of scenes where they chase whales and talk about sadness and soup. Also at one point, a whale cries, which shows it has deep feelings. Edwin feels bad about whale hunting and gives a speech that makes everyone cry, even the whale. Then they stop whaling forever and open a soup shop instead. Classic Dickens."

My favorite part was when the whale winked at Edwin and said (I remember this exactly), “Thou hast freed me, small land boy.” It was very emotional and definitely something Charles Dickens would write.

I learned that whales are smart and it’s better to sell soup than to hunt majestic creatures of the sea. This book had a lot of good messages and totally real facts.

I give this book 6 out of 5 stars because it was amazing and real. Also, I couldn’t find the book cover online because it’s probably banned or hidden in a secret library for rare readers."

***

Gentle readers, I will confess I snort-laughed at "yo-ho, melancholy," The machine has been trained on Dave Barry, undoubtedly without royalties.

Expand full comment
Doktor Zoom's avatar

Goddamn it, somewhere in there I did have my byline, and then I didn't, and now I do again.

Expand full comment
2631 more comments...

No posts