Discussion about this post

User's avatar
richardgrabman's avatar

I was always surprised at how popular biographies of Sherman are in southern bookstores. Then again, we're talking about the people who read and care about history. And there were a lot of southerners (including the 3/5th southerners) who welcomed Sherman as a liberator from the planter class.

Expand full comment
richardgrabman's avatar

"They press the case that you can't or shouldn't judge historical figures from the mores of today. Not even going to get into how fuckin' stupid that is."

Over-simplified, but not as stupid as you suggest. Should we not read Oscar Wilde because of his predeliction for adolescent boys? Focus on the planetary changes of the Colombian Exchange because the key figure could be an asshole by our standards? Are the personal failures (by our, or their own society's) the criteria for assessing historial significance?

Expand full comment
411 more comments...

No posts