Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shananigan's avatar

In Virginia, if the Governor is going to commute a death sentence, they are required to report their reasons to the Virginia General Assembly. Here's one Tim Kaine wrote when he DID commute someone's death sentence:

In issuing its ruling, the Fourth Circuit properly limited its consideration to psychiatric evaluations and other evidence pertaining to Walton’s mental state during the period from 1997 to 2003. By the time I first reviewed this matter, shortly before Walton’s scheduled execution in June 2006, three years had passed since the evidence on his mental competence was presented to the court.Due to the history of judicial concern about his mental status, I determined that it was important to have current and independent information about Walton’s mental condition in order to comply with the law forbidding execution of a mentally incompetent person. Accordingly, I delayed Walton’s June 2006 execution date until December 8, 2006, for the purpose of conducting an independent evaluation of his mental condition and competence.During that six-month period, I was provided with current and independent information pertaining to Walton’s mental state from a number of sources including a thorough review of records maintained by the Department of Corrections, updated evaluations by psychiatrists, and information provided by persons who had interacted with Walton on a regular basis over a period of years.In reaching the conclusion to commute Walton’s sentence to life in prison without possibility of parole, I recognize and respect the inherent obligation of each branch of government has to afford each to the others the dignity accorded by our separation of powers. Nonetheless, Article V, Section 12 of the Constitution of Virginia confers the extraordinary power of clemency on the Governor which the ends of justice call for the discharge of such duty, particularly where the exercise of that extraordinary power is, in my view, mandated by the Constitution of the United States of America.

I'm thinking "Because I'm Catholic and following my religious convictions" wouldn't really have cut it. I don't imagine your "I don't believe in the death penalty" would, either. A Governor can't just say "Naw, mang...I don't like it" and commute a sentence. There's a protocol involved.

http://www.americanbar.org/...

Expand full comment
Cat Cafe's avatar

"Hey, Hitler got REALLLY big crowds!! Look how big HIS crowds were!"

Expand full comment
274 more comments...

No posts