Discussion about this post

User's avatar
King Beauregard 👂's avatar

I love this bit. I don't even have to hit "play" to start laughing because I know what's coming. Eventually he'll say "dessert" and I shall lose it.

Expand full comment
King Beauregard 👂's avatar

True fact: the Ashokan Farewell isn't even an authentic Civil War song; it was written in the 1980s for an upstate New York folk festival (in Ashokan of all places). In that fashion it's a terrific metaphor for "The Civil War", which was Ken Burns' effort to educate people just enough with details about the Civil War while in reality being a 1980s revisionist version of the whole shooting match. Burns's main crime against education was trying to downplay how the South's entire motivation was slavery. Sure he mentions it as a factor, but the single issue upon which secession hung ... ? Oh that's a fact he tries very hard to avoid. In fact his tone about the Civil War is that it was a period of unpleasantness among brothers who really shouldn't have fought, and when peace finally became possible they mended fences and all was well. (Damn little mention of the Jim Crow that was necessary for white people to start getting along again.)

The clearest example of what I'm talking about, perhaps, is that Burns managed to find the Sullivan Ballou letter, yet he never mentioned the Declarations of Causes of Secession that several states drafted -- which made it 100% clear it was all about slavery. Or when Burns talked about the differences between the Confederate Constitution and the United States Constitution, and never mentioned all the elements that were added to preserve the institution of slavery in perpetuity. Damn peculiar oversight, that he left out the most significant changes in favor of mentioning the Confederate president's line-item veto.

Frankly I can't watch "The Civil War" any longer because I start yelling at my screen. Burns was that oily sort of historical presenter who had an agenda that he was clever enough to conceal from superficial scrutiny -- which tells me he knew the agenda was there.

Expand full comment
318 more comments...

No posts