Discussion about this post

User's avatar
WomanInThePersistence's avatar

I'll try again. Be good to yourself.

Expand full comment
Questionable Whackelpudding's avatar

I can answer that one: she won for Ghost, and not for The Color Purple. The Color Purple didn't win any Oscars. Not one. Out of Africa, a movie about the experiences of white people in Africa sure as hell did. (Though Meryl Streep did not win Best Actress. That went to Geraldine Page for A Trip to the Bountiful, and when was the last time you heard about THAT one?)

The apparent shut-out of The Color Purple is widely thought as one of the more shameful episodes in Oscar history. I'd put the win of Driving Miss Daisy as Best Picture when Do the Right Thing didn't even get a nod right up there, too. Time and again, when given the opportunity to recognize black voices on the experience of racism in America, the Academy has traditionally opted to award white perspectives, instead.

NOW, all that having been said, it has also been suggested that The Color Purple itself is a white perspective on black lives, since it was directed by Steven Spielberg, well known light-hued person. Spielberg himself has said that given the opportunity to do it again, he wouldn't have chosen to direct the film. It is unlikely, however, that the film could have been made without his name attached to it as director (his name attached as producer wasn't as big a deal at the time and, besides, has usually been a mixed blessing, at best -- though not the kiss of death that George Lucas's name has traditionally been). Of course, after saying that, he went and directed Amistad, so who knows?

I've heard it suggested that Whoopi's win for Ghost was an apology for her earlier loss, but I don't personally buy that. First of all, it isn't as if her performance in Ghost was bad. And second of all, it kind of implies that she isn't good enough to have turned in more than one Oscar-worthy performance in the first place. Hell, I'd go so far as to say that she's deserved nominations for some of her work in movies that clearly aren't Oscar-worthy. She's elevated some otherwise completely unwatchable material (Burglar fairly screams to mind).

Expand full comment
2868 more comments...

No posts