Discussion about this post

User's avatar
SullivanSt's avatar

Sure, life expectancy at birth for the whole population is always totally representative of that of the elite.

That's why there's such a close relationship between Carson's 47 and the age at which the first Chief Justice, John Jay, died (83). Of course, Jay only sat on the bench for 6 years before resigning to run for Governor of New York, but that has nothing to do with life expectancy.

Clearly all the Founding Fathers were dead and buried long before John Marshall served 34 years as Chief Justice and it's only for that reason they didn't do anything about the possibility that a life appointment could mean a long time. Oh, wait, Thomas Jefferson and John Adams were alive the first 25 years of his term. Huh! Obviously John Adams wasn't paying attention, I mean it's not like he appointed the guy or anything... OR IS IT? (Yes, it is).

Expand full comment
Pinball or Submission's avatar

I don't know whether Carson's cited life expectancy of 47 is accurate, but if it is that was average for everybody, certainly not average for Supreme Court Justices. The average life span of Washington's original 5 Justices was almost 69 years old. John Jay lived to 83, and William Cushing served for over 20 years. And the issue of lifetime appointments isn't that big of a deal considering in the last 60 years, only Scalia and Rehnquist have died in office while 17 other Justices have retired or resigned.

Expand full comment
310 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?