Discussion about this post

User's avatar
swmnguy's avatar

Why do we allow Prosecutors to behave in monstrous fashion? No civilized nation tries children as adults. In fact, we only have age restrictions on anything; voting, alcohol, smoking, military service, binding legal contracts; because we know that children are not adults, and that children are not adults until the age of at least 18 and quite possibly 21.

So under what perversion of logic and humanity do we allow Prosecutors to violate everything we know about human development, to win politically-motivated victories? And those who do not believe Prosecutors are politicians, have a look at the ballot next time you go and vote, and look at how many candidates for all offices including but in no way limited to Prosecutor, are or have been Prosecutors.

No doubt this woman was a dangerous mess when she killed her purchaser/rapist. I imagine that sort of trauma would leave a mark. Such people are not easy to deal with. And America's perverse and barbaric prison system, which would make a Turkish jailer shudder, is no place for a traumatized, abused, dumpster-fire of a trafficked girl.

Thank former Gov. Haslam for finding the courage to do the right thing at the very last possible second, when he could no longer wring any benefit out of this woman's continued torture. That should earn him a couple degrees-lower roasting in Hell for eternity; whatta guy.

The larger issue is, when are we going to re-orient our criminal "justice" system around the needs and benefits of American Society, rather than the political ambitions of Prosecutors and the blood-lust of our for-profit media to stoke primitive, atavistic revenge-fantasies.

Expand full comment
Dr. Rrrrrobotnik's avatar

I don't follow, is that a specific offense in Tennessee that I'm not aware of? As far as I could tell from the NYT article, they had sex that wasn't due to violent coercion but was still statutory rape due to her age.

I think people are mistaking who she killed: she didn't kill her pimp, who violently raped her and forced her into underage prostitution, but a john.

Expand full comment
462 more comments...

No posts