17 Comments

Big part of the reason for the rarity of section 3 cases is the height of the bar that must be cleared - DOJ must prove intentional racial discrimination, and that has happened openly outside of the section 4 jurisdictions very often. Of course, the redistricting smack down <em>did</em> have a judge acknowledging intentional racial discrimination, but there was no need at the tine, and hence no request for, "bail-in".

The other issue with section 3 is the court which monitors per clearance is the circuit which covers the state, cf section 5 where the cases all go to the DC circuit, so there's also the matter of encountering ultra conservative judges who don't give a crap what the law is as long as their side wins.

Anyway, section 3 is the very model of what the decision striking section 4 down says VRA type legislation should look like, they'd have to engage in really breathtakingly shocking hypocrisy, even measured by their own exacting standards, to strike it down too.

Expand full comment

Re: a) Seems like a partial success in the NASA sense, unless the alcocubes melted on their way to the punchbowl.

Expand full comment

It's almost as if each of them has some sort of characteristic that distinguishes them from the general conservative vision of what a politician should look like.

Expand full comment

You been on vaca? I was beginning to worry something was wrong.

Expand full comment

You have to wonder why, with all the South to choose from, they chose LYNCHburg for its location.

Expand full comment

<i>We’re pretty sure you can get a J.D. from Liberty by doing nothing more than reading the New Testament and mailing in the proof of purchase from a cereal box.</i>

Slackers. It's the OLD Testament that has all the smiting, killing, hating, slavery, wimmim-bondage stuff the GOP really digs.

Please pass that box of Jeebus Fruity Flakes, please.

Expand full comment

Do you really have to wonder?

Expand full comment

i hear that eric holder is not white.

Expand full comment

Once again Texas lives down to its "one star state" reputation.

Expand full comment

That is good news for al Queda! I hope they remember to thank the NRA this Christmas.

Expand full comment

They worship glory in all its forms.

Expand full comment

Do these guys think they can tell the ocean tide not to come in? Isn't Texas is already "majority minority" for children under 5? Is this going to change? They can get away with maybe 6-8 more years of this stuff and not worry about paying the piper?

Expand full comment

Ever notice that the claim that racism in America no longer exists comes from the same right-wing sites whose comment sections for years have functioned as cesspools of openly racist commentary and insults.

Or am I overthinking this?

Expand full comment

Wait. The Supreme Court repealed the 14th Amendment?

Expand full comment

An uneven trade--for Mexico.

Expand full comment

When Putin and Snowden review Holder's assertions that Snowden won't be tortured, they should be sure to inquire as to whether the John Yoo definition of torture is the one Holder's talking about.

Expand full comment