Looks like their official account of the event is gonna keep looking worse 🙄 . . .
Tim Miller @Timodc
The idea that this man feared for his life in that moment is insane. She has a friendly exchange with him 20 seconds before and the car is going 2 miles an hour!!
Quote
Alpha News @AlphaNews
·
1h
BREAKING: Alpha News has obtained cellphone footage showing perspective of federal agent at center of ICE-involved shooting in Minneapolis
1:05 PM · Jan 9, 2026
·
Tim Miller @Timodc
This video shows clearly that he knew it was a middle aged white lady who showed no signs of menace. It also shows that he could clearly see her turning the wheel to the right to leave. He murdered her.
·
33m
The victim calmly says “that’s fine dude i’m not mad at you” to the ice agent 20 seconds before he murders her.
·
29m
After killing Renee Good one of the ICE agents says “fucking bitch”
What's odd is I went to the Alpha News page out of curiosity just now (several hours later from when I first saw this here) and they seem to have taken out the "fucking bitch" part. Kind of too late, though, since I guess that version is out there still.
These are terrorists? A smiling woman saying "I'm not mad at you" and another woman armed with a phone making a joke about lunch? These are the people you couldn't handle without bullets?
I'm sure they're encouraged to believe that it's okay to kill any citizen who offends their crazed right-wing sensibilities or makes them even a little bit nervous. In 2026, what kind of vile person wants to be an ICE agent?
For those of you not familiar with Alpha News it’s a right wing propaganda/copaganda site based in Minnesota. The lead reporter is Liz Collin who is married to Bob Kroll, former head of the Minneapolis Police Union. I’m not saying that this footage was leaked for a reason but I’m not not saying it.
Why was he recording with his cell phone? Was he was planning to shoot and wanted to capture it on video for his own purposes? I mean, it’s weird that he was using his phone at the same time as aiming the gun, right?
I happened to be in the car when NPR All Things Considered came on today and they said that JD Vance posted this video on Twitter, which makes it suspect indeed.
So did a bunch of cretins in the comments to at least one post of the video on X. If the car hit him hard enough to make all the jumpiness he'd be on the ground.
Doesn't anyone think it's odd that this video is out a day after the FBI was unwilling to assist Minnesota's investigation?
I would argue that the only part that matters is the final three or four seconds. And those are such a blur they could easily have been manipulated to suit the DHS narrative.
When the officer starts walking back across the front of the car, that is contrary to what I recall from the initial bystander video, where he was walking out of the path of the vehicle.
I am willing to believe the worst about ICE agents in every instance. They have given up all claims to the benefit of the doubt.
- THAT SAID -
The fact remains that doctored and/or AI-generated footage is a possibility no matter *what* you're looking at. We have to be careful about accepting the authenticity of *any* video or audio, unless A) it comes too close on the heels of the event for fakery to be a possibility, or B) it's been through some sort of technical check that someone like a major news outlet or state (*not* federal, unfortunately) agency has the means to implement.
And ultimately Rather's story on Bush and the Air Guard was completely factual...he was deliberately leaked fake documents which he was told were real to discredit him inspite of the facts being undeniable.
Alpha News is a right wing propaganda site based in Minnesota. The lead reporter, Liz Collin, is married to Bob Kroll, former head of the Minneapolis Police Union. I’m not watching the video but I wouldn’t be surprised if there was some editing done.
We are dealing with sociopathic pieces of shit and corporations who, for whatever reason, refuse to back up their own terms of service and let such horrid comments stay.
"Hoping" it will end soon is not going to do a damn thing to make it end soon. We absolutely must organize, engage with our communities, and support one another during situations like ICE visits. They'd like to kill all of us, but then, who'd be left to kill?
I find it interesting that our internet and phones are, by design, a centrally controlled network instead of an independent, distributed, person to person mesh network that they can’t turn off. No reason things can’t work that way with the radio tech these days and the sheer number of devices now. It would probably work way better. Self healing, no big outages. But nope.
Ernst Frankel's Nazi-era book "The Dual State" is more relevant than ever. The idea is that Hitler's Germany had basically two tracks of government--one that was more or less normal (trash pickup, civil court cases, and so forth), and one that served a totally unaccountable terror state where normal rules simply didn't apply. Meaning that the state on that track can do absolutely anything it wants, and you have no recourse. We have arrived at this "Dual State." These ICE agents are unaccountable to anyone but America's Demented Orange Hitler, and he is obviously encouraging them to terrorize the public without fear of even the slightest consequences.
Even if the new video is taken as real and at face value, he still murdered Renee Good. He stepped in front of the car, so far as I can tell, after she began moving. So he put himself there in order to have an excuse to kill her.
The assumption of all of this is that ICE did not know Renee Good, and she did not know them. BUT, what if they did know her? She's a Lesbian woman who has, according to multiple press reports, been performing as an "observer" of ICE events. What if they saw her getting into her car, recognized her, and decided to "teach the Bitch a lesson?" Just saying. With all of their surveillance it's not out of the question. I'm sure they're building files on ICE demo participants across the country.
She had not been a part of any protests prior to that morning, when the school where she was dropping off her first-grader was being besieged by the ICE.
The ICEhole committed first degree murder. He's been stoking his rage for months. He has many accomplices - his supervisor, Greg Bovino, Kristi Noem, Stephen Miller, Russell Vought, Donald Trump. These are all accomplices BEFORE the fact. They are all chargeable with first degree murder. There's plenty of malice and all the murdering was planned. Hang the lot in accordance with the law.
ICE would have killed the citizens who hid Anne Frank and her family. The Nazi comparison is getting further and further from hyperbole. ICE is our equivalent of the German SS. We will, or maybe already have had, our own Krystallknacht. The boiling point. The moment history will recognize with shame, the moment American authorities looked on without intervening. Completely agree with the shock that Trump’s political career didn’t end after January 6th. I have a better understanding of the German citizens who opposed the Nazis in silence. The fear and terror is the point. That is how they silence good people. They have weapons and aren’t afraid to use them on their fellow citizens. Any they have zero consequences when they do. I feel so helpless. Even members of my own family can’t agree that this is wrong. Thank you for the reminder that we have to keep hope alive. As we become hopeless and scared, they get emboldened. We must make them understand that they do not have a mandate.
If ever thine TURBO-ENCABULATOR hast needs of repairment waver not to summon KRISTI of the CLAN NOEM! It is shown multitudes on the hill sides how ever to shun yon minecraft fields.
Looks like their official account of the event is gonna keep looking worse 🙄 . . .
Tim Miller @Timodc
The idea that this man feared for his life in that moment is insane. She has a friendly exchange with him 20 seconds before and the car is going 2 miles an hour!!
Quote
Alpha News @AlphaNews
·
1h
BREAKING: Alpha News has obtained cellphone footage showing perspective of federal agent at center of ICE-involved shooting in Minneapolis
1:05 PM · Jan 9, 2026
·
Tim Miller @Timodc
This video shows clearly that he knew it was a middle aged white lady who showed no signs of menace. It also shows that he could clearly see her turning the wheel to the right to leave. He murdered her.
·
33m
The victim calmly says “that’s fine dude i’m not mad at you” to the ice agent 20 seconds before he murders her.
·
29m
After killing Renee Good one of the ICE agents says “fucking bitch”
https://xcancel.com/Timodc/status/2009687922086425035
What's odd is I went to the Alpha News page out of curiosity just now (several hours later from when I first saw this here) and they seem to have taken out the "fucking bitch" part. Kind of too late, though, since I guess that version is out there still.
These are terrorists? A smiling woman saying "I'm not mad at you" and another woman armed with a phone making a joke about lunch? These are the people you couldn't handle without bullets?
I'm sure they're encouraged to believe that it's okay to kill any citizen who offends their crazed right-wing sensibilities or makes them even a little bit nervous. In 2026, what kind of vile person wants to be an ICE agent?
"An armed society is a polite society"
That's gotta be first degree murder. Just an absolutely fragile scumbag.
I can't believe I just saw that
"Go get yourself some lunch, big boy." LOL- that's what triggered him.
Hurt gravy seal's feefees.
For those of you not familiar with Alpha News it’s a right wing propaganda/copaganda site based in Minnesota. The lead reporter is Liz Collin who is married to Bob Kroll, former head of the Minneapolis Police Union. I’m not saying that this footage was leaked for a reason but I’m not not saying it.
The lies don’t work. The video is more evidence it was murder. He held his phone in his other hand in record mode the whole time.
He walked away uninjured as if he’d just done cricket in the gravel pit.
Why was he recording with his cell phone? Was he was planning to shoot and wanted to capture it on video for his own purposes? I mean, it’s weird that he was using his phone at the same time as aiming the gun, right?
Clearly not in fear of his life. He was mad she didn’t fear him, so he shot her.
VD Vance declares ICE has absolute immunity.
Dear Schumer, we are here. We are past constitutional crisis, and moved into fascist state.
Alpha News is right wing, and they leaked the video that exonerates Renee Good? Weird thing for them to do, but we'll take it.
I happened to be in the car when NPR All Things Considered came on today and they said that JD Vance posted this video on Twitter, which makes it suspect indeed.
The video suggests the officer was hit. I think they doctored the ending for that effect. It's not what I saw in the witness video on Wednesday.
The jumpiness of the video occurs from gun recoil. Vance ignorantly thought it meant the car actually struck him.
So did a bunch of cretins in the comments to at least one post of the video on X. If the car hit him hard enough to make all the jumpiness he'd be on the ground.
There was a loud thump, but I didn't hear the gunshots...
Lots of the nasty commenters were claiming that it exonerated the guy.
That’s ludicrous
They might be so deranged that they think this puts the pig in some sort of good light.
The comments suggest that was the case. At least a lot of them did.
This. The women were being smarties and said mean things.
But she didn't say anything mean. It says they had a friendly exchange?
Their play must be, "She was no angel"
Not a hetero woman, she deserves to be "punished."
They probably think it’s justification. Noem did shoot a puppy in the face and brag about it.
Speaking of which, this video shows a dog sitting in the back seat.
Well, if somebody thought this helped his case, they were sadly mistaken . . . I'm not sure what other motive there might have been . . .
Whatever, the video is all over X now . . . and everyone's yapping about it . . .
That’s the shooter’s cellphone video. The ONLY way it could have been obtained is if he was live streaming, he posted it, or ICE released it.
One other possibility… a good guy with the FBI.
Do you really think there are any left? Serious question, no snark intended.
Yeah, there are. Heads down right now because they know that they will be needed.
Yeah. Exactly as we were all thinking, isn't it? These people are enemy combatants and terrorists, and should be treated as such.
Doesn't anyone think it's odd that this video is out a day after the FBI was unwilling to assist Minnesota's investigation?
I would argue that the only part that matters is the final three or four seconds. And those are such a blur they could easily have been manipulated to suit the DHS narrative.
When the officer starts walking back across the front of the car, that is contrary to what I recall from the initial bystander video, where he was walking out of the path of the vehicle.
I am willing to believe the worst about ICE agents in every instance. They have given up all claims to the benefit of the doubt.
- THAT SAID -
The fact remains that doctored and/or AI-generated footage is a possibility no matter *what* you're looking at. We have to be careful about accepting the authenticity of *any* video or audio, unless A) it comes too close on the heels of the event for fakery to be a possibility, or B) it's been through some sort of technical check that someone like a major news outlet or state (*not* federal, unfortunately) agency has the means to implement.
Just sayin.'
They are maximum ACAB and already clearly see themselves as a Band Apart Gang...
Yes I remember exactly what happened to Dan Rather. This is a hazard for Democrats only; rightwingers are free to use doctored videos all they like.
And ultimately Rather's story on Bush and the Air Guard was completely factual...he was deliberately leaked fake documents which he was told were real to discredit him inspite of the facts being undeniable.
Alpha News is a right wing propaganda site based in Minnesota. The lead reporter, Liz Collin, is married to Bob Kroll, former head of the Minneapolis Police Union. I’m not watching the video but I wouldn’t be surprised if there was some editing done.
Thank you for the info! I just went to look on their front page, and wouldn't you know it, it has this very distinct wingnut propaganda vibe.
Happy to be of service. :)
I don't know much about Alpha News . . . it might be MN-based . . . whatever, footage appears legit . . .
Don’t. Read. The comments.
I made the mistake of doing that.
We are dealing with sociopathic pieces of shit and corporations who, for whatever reason, refuse to back up their own terms of service and let such horrid comments stay.
How about you fuck yourself you Nazi piece of shit?
One of them better say 37 is not middle aged, you punk-assed kid.
Yeah . . . some are pretty brutal 😩
Brutally stupid.
that's fine, I didn't need to be less enraged than I already was
This bitch WILL return fire on these motherfuckers.
The Cane of Justice is always at the ready!
"Hoping" it will end soon is not going to do a damn thing to make it end soon. We absolutely must organize, engage with our communities, and support one another during situations like ICE visits. They'd like to kill all of us, but then, who'd be left to kill?
Ta, Marcie. We said Kaddish for Renee Nicole Good last night. These actions *must* start having consequences.
I have a fantasy where Pope Leo excommunicates JD for being publicly pro-murder.
“It’s a wonder they don’t oops-shoot their own more often.”
OMG! That would be terrible!!!
Take a burner smartphone to protests, gotcha
not stopping.
me and my whistle and my beloved 6000 miles of chi streets bike are
not stopping.
I find it interesting that our internet and phones are, by design, a centrally controlled network instead of an independent, distributed, person to person mesh network that they can’t turn off. No reason things can’t work that way with the radio tech these days and the sheer number of devices now. It would probably work way better. Self healing, no big outages. But nope.
Ernst Frankel's Nazi-era book "The Dual State" is more relevant than ever. The idea is that Hitler's Germany had basically two tracks of government--one that was more or less normal (trash pickup, civil court cases, and so forth), and one that served a totally unaccountable terror state where normal rules simply didn't apply. Meaning that the state on that track can do absolutely anything it wants, and you have no recourse. We have arrived at this "Dual State." These ICE agents are unaccountable to anyone but America's Demented Orange Hitler, and he is obviously encouraging them to terrorize the public without fear of even the slightest consequences.
Report the account "Subhuman Society for Filth" for threatening us all with violence and extermination.
done
Even if the new video is taken as real and at face value, he still murdered Renee Good. He stepped in front of the car, so far as I can tell, after she began moving. So he put himself there in order to have an excuse to kill her.
The assumption of all of this is that ICE did not know Renee Good, and she did not know them. BUT, what if they did know her? She's a Lesbian woman who has, according to multiple press reports, been performing as an "observer" of ICE events. What if they saw her getting into her car, recognized her, and decided to "teach the Bitch a lesson?" Just saying. With all of their surveillance it's not out of the question. I'm sure they're building files on ICE demo participants across the country.
She had not been a part of any protests prior to that morning, when the school where she was dropping off her first-grader was being besieged by the ICE.
Thank You Marcie for including 404 Media. They have broken so many stories about LEO use of apps and websites to stalk people
The ICEhole committed first degree murder. He's been stoking his rage for months. He has many accomplices - his supervisor, Greg Bovino, Kristi Noem, Stephen Miller, Russell Vought, Donald Trump. These are all accomplices BEFORE the fact. They are all chargeable with first degree murder. There's plenty of malice and all the murdering was planned. Hang the lot in accordance with the law.
Shouldn't be too tough for AI to build a 3D walkthrough of the murder scene with all the available video.
On another note, how many deer rifles do you suppose are in MSP?
Funny how the gun-humpers say they need their guns to protect themselves from the Feds, yet when the time comes, they cheer them on.
ICE would have killed the citizens who hid Anne Frank and her family. The Nazi comparison is getting further and further from hyperbole. ICE is our equivalent of the German SS. We will, or maybe already have had, our own Krystallknacht. The boiling point. The moment history will recognize with shame, the moment American authorities looked on without intervening. Completely agree with the shock that Trump’s political career didn’t end after January 6th. I have a better understanding of the German citizens who opposed the Nazis in silence. The fear and terror is the point. That is how they silence good people. They have weapons and aren’t afraid to use them on their fellow citizens. Any they have zero consequences when they do. I feel so helpless. Even members of my own family can’t agree that this is wrong. Thank you for the reminder that we have to keep hope alive. As we become hopeless and scared, they get emboldened. We must make them understand that they do not have a mandate.
If ever thine TURBO-ENCABULATOR hast needs of repairment waver not to summon KRISTI of the CLAN NOEM! It is shown multitudes on the hill sides how ever to shun yon minecraft fields.