Discussion about this post

User's avatar
marxalot's avatar

I can totally see how Gaby's hero worship of Xena, combined with her own character development arc, would intersect with Eowyn's, either as a "poor decisions/substitute" a "we both have the same problem" or a more healthy "ships that pass in the night/comrades in arms" style interaction. And both of them eventually step up to be god-killers, so this ain't EVEN a sidekick sidequest story.

Expand full comment
dirtdog's avatar

We're getting way OT and this is an old thread, but I had a thought about timelines. Gaby was on episodic television of >100 shows with some long-term story arc but lots of one-off encounters with people from all over various mythologies -- putting her in Middle Earth at any moment presents no problem and I'm sure the show would have done it if the Tolkien estate didn't have a reputation for strongly defending their canon. Eowyn, on the other hand, we see for a very brief period going through some fast phases: daughter taking care of father bewitched by Saruman, infatuated by Aragorn, rejected by Aragorn and going off to war as a death-seeking berserker, and then happily-ever-after with Faramir. I don't think the encounter can happen within the time of TLOTR. Two scenarios: Eowyn in Rohan as a younger girl/woman wanting to be a warrior in a place where that is not expected of women, and encountering Gaby in her badass amazon-queen mode who inspires Eowyn to become what she eventually does. Eowyn in Ithilien as wife of Faramir, encountering Gaby while she's still wearing a long skirt and hasn't encountered the Amazons, still cleaning some remnant orcs out of Ithilien and inspiring Gaby to be more than a sidekick.

I think badass Gaby inspiring young Eowyn would be easier to construct. If you do anything with any of these ideas or go someplace totally on your own, please do a reply that lets me find it. It's totally off topic, but I've enjoyed thinking about this the last few days.

Expand full comment
297 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?