16 Comments

The problem with this idea is that it can be made to succeed; not by marginal isolated nutjobs, but I'm sure that DARPA has a serious effort underway somewhere to produce a deadly directed-energy weapon for battlefield use, and maybe political/military assassinations too. The highly collimated beam of microwaves produced by a MASER is an obvious candidate device. Remember that Reagan's 'Star Wars' initiative to destroy ballistic missiles rising into space wasn't derailed because such a directed-energy technology couldn't be produced, but because too many fraudulent targets could be generated by the missile launching source.

Expand full comment

"No, we are most interested in how two people with engineering backgrounds [...] would actually waste so much of their time and effort on trying to do something that the laws of physics say you pretty much cannot do."

Well, you did note that Crawford worked for GE, so there's a big chunk of your answer right there. They smoke some really weird shit in the Electric City.

Phasers on stun.

Expand full comment

He was killed by a Chevy?

Expand full comment

I know that there feller on that there disc cover thingy!

Expand full comment

Steve Irwin didn't believe in Death Rays either.

Expand full comment

Not tonight, I have a headache.

Plus 15 years of neglect have allowed most of my physics training to evaporate. I couldn't even find a Sturm Liouville eigenbasis any more, let alone solve a Feynman path integral.

Expand full comment

They needed the super awesome vapor death ray to eliminate threats to their freedumb.

Expand full comment

Gotta be better than Sugar Ray.

Expand full comment

It wasn't a deep tissue damage ray, it was a death ray supposed to achieve its end result "within days". Also, even with optics because of diffraction you simply cannot achieve a perfectly collimated beam and it's still an inverse square law, you've just applied a constant factor, unless you have an actual X-ray laser (which still self-diffracts, btw, but that's not important at this kind of range)

Expand full comment

<blockquote>The central difficulty in building a working version of the alleged device is the nature of how radiation works. The intensity of radiation diminishes rapidly as you move away from the source — it’s an inverse-square relationship between intensity and distance. </blockquote>

Actually, since this was a radiation death ray, it's worse than that. It's inverse square <em>in vacuo</em>, but with air in the way it's inverse square times exponential decay. The decay factor depends on the exact type of radiation - they were engineers so I presume it was gamma, because alpha wouldn't have made it out the end of the device and beta wouldn't have made it out of the van the device was going to be concealed in, but even so, to quote Napoleon Dynamite: "Freakin' idiot!"

Expand full comment

I see your inverse cube law and raise you an exponential decay from absorption.

Expand full comment

When death rays are outlawed, only criminals will have death rays.

Second Amendment remedies come in all wavelengths.

I'm withholding judgment until I hear from NDRA CEO Wayne LaPee'er.

Expand full comment

Then I revise my earlier statement. This was clearly NOT terrorism.

It is just a sad case of two men who have suffered and been persecuted too long by an intrusive and deceptive government. While what they did is inexcusable, it is certainly understandable, in light of the years of cruel oppression they have been forced to endure.

The sad truth is that cases like these are easily preventable by simply kow-towing to the wishes of even the most extreme fringe groups on the right.

(This is my FOX news demo. Whatchoo guys think, have I got a shot?)

Expand full comment

Yes. A Liberal take on 1984, wherein they are the heroes.

Expand full comment

NSA - the new Takers.

Expand full comment

They shopped the idea to the KKK.

The KKK was founded by Democrats.

Therefore, these guys were Democrats.

My immense powers of logical deduction clearly show that this is not a case of reverse-terrorism. Just your run-of-the-mill Democratic Racist Terrorism. Alinksyism for those from the old school, Obamaism for those from the new.

Expand full comment