Parrot Pining For The Witness Box, May Provide Evidence In Michigan Murder Case
This is an ex-parte! Err, parrot!
A foul-mouthed African grey parrot named Bud might be entered into evidence in a Michigan murder trial, maybe. Probably not, but maybe. Bud may have overheard the murder of his owner, Martin Duram, in 2015, and since shortly after the murder, the parrot been repeating what sounds like an argument between a man and a woman, ending with the phrase "Don't fucking shoot!" That last line is apparently Bud's favorite phrase. Newaygo County Prosecuting Attorney Robert Springstead told the Detroit Free Press that he's at least considering whether Bud's parrot talk could be admissible evidence.
“It’s an interesting novelty and it’s been a great opportunity for me to learn about African parrots,” he says. “It is something we are going to be looking at to determine if it’s reliable to use or if it's information we need to prosecute this case.”
Martin Duram's wife, Glenna, was charged last week with killing him, after which she shot herself in the head in an unsuccessful suicide attempt. Glenna Duram was Martin's caretaker, and police interviews with family members obtained by WXMI indicate that they often argued; she would sometimes comment that she was "just waiting for Marty to die to get all his money." State police say they found three suicide notes written by Glenna Durham, and that the gun used in the shootings belonged to the family; she denies killing her husband and has no memory of the shooting.
So obviously, the parrot is the best possible witness, at least if the world is a really bad movie.
Duram's family believes the parrot has been mimicking the couple's final argument, ending with the line "Don't fucking shoot!" Bud's new owner, Duram's ex, Christina Keller, says the bird "replays" an angry disagreement:
“I’m hearing two people in an intense argument,” said Keller, who believes “Don’t f—ing shoot!” were Duram’s final words. “Two people that I know, voices that I recognize.”
“It’s intense,” she added. “When it happens, my house turns cold.”
Keller had no comment on the bird's beautiful plumage, which don't enter into it.
Springstead told a Michigan teeveee station last week that there's no precedent for using a parrot's words as evidence, saying he
“highly doubts there is any precedent” for using a bird’s speech as evidence. When a judge asks someone to raise their right hand, he wondered, “to a parrot, are you raising a wing, a foot?”
This would be especially difficult if the parrot's feet had been nailed to the perch, a step that has not been taken considering that Bud has not rung down the curtain or joined the choir invisible. It's his former owner, after all, who's pushin' up the daisies.
A pet shop owner in Grand Rapids, Doreen Plotkowski, told WABC-TV that African grey parrots commonly mimic male and female voices:
"It's definitely an argument between a man and a woman," she said... "In my mind, it's something that he's heard, definitely heard before."
The Washington Post dutifully notes at least one legal expert (if we were a TV news station, we'd call him a "legal eagle," but we are above that sort of thing -- just barely) doubts whether Bud's vocalizations would be admissible as evidence:
Michael Walsh, a Muskegon, Mich., lawyer, told WOOD-TV that the bird is inadmissible because there’s no way to trace his dirty mouth.
“How did it get there?” Walsh said, referring to Bud’s words. “If there’s no reliable way of making that determination, you can’t rule out that the bird witnessed a homicide or that the bird witnessed something on TV.”
Sadly, Walsh didn't then follow his analysis by insisting that any district attorney attempting to use a bird as evidence would soon find their case bereft of life, gone to meet its maker, off the twig, and all in all, an ex-prosecution. Then the police would step in and bring a sudden end to the proceedings, declaring them extremely silly.
Doktor Zoom's real name is Marty Kelley, and he lives in the wilds of Boise, Idaho. He is not a medical doctor, but does have a real PhD in Rhetoric. You should definitely donate some money to this little mommyblog where he has finally found acceptance and cat pictures. He is on maternity leave until 2033. Here is his Twitter, also. His quest to avoid prolixity is not going so great.