Makeup Brand That Sold 'Black Face Paint' Foundation Finally 'Addresses' Controversy. Somewhat.
Makeup Brand That Sold 'Black Face Paint' Foundation Finally 'Addresses' Controversy. Somewhat.
Poorly! They did it very poorly!
Back in April, in response to criticism over the lack of darker shades in their Date Night foundation line, the makeup company Youthforia finally came out with a shade for darker skin tones. A much, much darker skin tone.
Actually, what they came out with was black face paint. Just straight up black face paint with one single pigment in it — iron oxide. Now, there is a reason that no other makeup company (except perhaps those who once catered to Al Jolson) has ever made the bold move of putting out a pure black foundation before, and that is because there is no human being on earth with pure black skin and no undertones. When foundation is mixed, it’s with varying degrees of red, blue and yellow.
Unsurprisingly, this move did not go over very well! TikToker Golloria went viral with her review of the product, demonstrating how it was indistinguishable from black face paint.
Tiktok failed to load.Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser
This video, which racked up over three million views, came out on April 29. Since then, countless other videos have been made criticizing the brand for … whatever the hell this was supposed to be.
And up until last week, the brand said nothing about it. Not one word. As it turns out, that may have been the better move, as the way they did finally address it was actually worse. Instead of mentioning the controversy, they posted a job opening on Instagram.
“We are creating a new position internally dedicated to examining both our current products and those in development so we can best meet your needs,” the post read. The oddly long ad is for one single position, titled Director of Product Developmentm who will be in charge of doing the jobs of approximately 17 people, including director of product development, chief diversity officer, project manager, marketer and whatever you call someone who would be in charge of regulatory compliance.
And, again, there was no apology, acknowledgement of the situation and the product itself is still for sale on the site.
As you can see in the picture above, there are twice as many shades for white skin as there are for Black skin. This is certainly not because white people have a wider range of shades.
While makeup companies have always offered a wider range of shades for light and medium skin, it’s actually only very recently that more are doing the same for darker skin tones. More plainly, a whole lot of makeup companies — aside from MAC and some others — just straight up ignored the existence of Black people or thought they could throw in a few darker shades at the end and call it a day.
In fact, it actually wasn’t until Fenty debuted with a 40 (now 50) shade foundation line in 2017 that more brands started to really offer more inclusive options. Yes, you read that right. 2017. In fact, part of the reason Rihanna started Fenty in the first place was because she had her own issues with shade matching whenever she was getting her makeup done and wanted to be sure everyone felt included. And now, 40 shades or more is the new standard (depending on the formulation, obviously lighter-coverage foundations don’t have to be as wide-ranging). It is no longer acceptable to put out a line of foundations with 15 shades, most of which are light or medium.
It should be very clear to makeup brands by now that if they cannot offer an inclusive line of foundations, then they should not bother releasing one at all. People will not accept it, and they shouldn’t have to.
It should also be clear to companies in general that if they hired a more diverse workforce from the outset, they would be a lot less likely to end up in situations like this and try to make up for it last minute by scrambling to find a product development director who can also DEI them up. Because then, they might have more people to ask “Hey, should we rebrand Shinola shoe polish as a foundation instead of just releasing a normal range of deeper shades?” and could be told “No, not unless you are trying to bring minstrel shows back, which you also should not try to do.”
It’s not that hard.
PREVIOUSLY:
I could see it IF they were like "WE UNDERSTAND SKIN COMES IN EVERY COLOUR, HERE'S A MIX-YOUR-OWN SYSTEM" (because holy smokes could I get behind that, between contour, foundation, highlighter and skin changes throughout the year and with time...)
But no. Just Vantablack, for no one.
Two stories. I worked most of my life in a lab. The lab worked 7 days a week so all of us pulled some overtime. One weekend I was working with a young black lady. Only she looked different that day. Her face was all splotchy, like she had been beat up or something, So I asked if she was all right. She said "yes" she just didn't have time to put on her makeup. She just had really uneven skin tone. That was the first that I knew black people have that problem. Boy, did I feel embarrassed.
The other story isn't really a story. Another person in the lab was an immigrant from Africa. His skin was the blackest I have ever seen on a person. Probably not blackface level of black but darn close.