Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Martini Glambassador's avatar

Summer corn: even porcupines love the stuff (it’s your hed gif source info link)-https://open.substack.com/pub/martiniambassador/p/porcupine-porkin-out?r=angu9&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Expand full comment
R. Riddle's avatar

“Why does JD Vance look at his grandmother, pregnant from 13 on, never finishing middle school, with a violent husband and piles of miscarriages, and want that for the rest of us?”

I’m going to discuss something I’ve never publicly revealed. A couple of years back, as part of regular screenings of movies in my home theater with friends, we watched “The Banshees of Inisherin”.

As we sat and watched the movie, I realized, about half-way through it, that I was having a panic attack.

I grew up in Appalachia, in an isolated hill community in northwest NC, went to college, and wound up having a 30 year career at two nationally ranked universities as a staff member. My brother and I were the first in our family to move away and leave that community.

“The Banshees” set off many terrible, deep set memories of trauma from my childhood that I had just buried and not thought about in many years. I got through the entire film (having to step away a couple of times to compose myself). But it made me realize something very fundamental about my own hometown in Appalachia, but isolated rural communities in general.

My father’s side of the family originally came from Scotland; my mother’s from Germany. Both families came to these shores in the early 1700s. What I saw in “Banshees” were all the archetypes of our families - the feuds between families and branches that would be handed down and perpetuated from generation to generation, the senseless acts of revenge or acting out that would turn violent, the deep-set mistrust of outsiders and any kind of change, the constant gossip and misunderstandings, the senseless and selfish ideas about “personal honor” or the roles of men and and women. Mostly, it was the feeling of helplessness that “it’s the way things are and you can never change anything”.

The character of the sister in the movie was me - the bookish lady who looked to the outside world who finally said, “Fuck it - I’m out of here. You people are crazy and can wallow in your bullshit forever, but I want no part of it,” as she caught the next boat off the island for a job in the city.

There are basically two kinds of families in every isolated rural community I’ve visited or lived in since. There are parents, like my dad or uncle, who were forced to leave because things got so bad with the poverty or family dysfunction, that they left for work and another life or were drafted into the military. They saw the outside world and understood that their kids could have a better life and encouraged them to get an education and have a better life. Then there were others who remained, perpetuating the same problems, and usually wound up getting mired in domestic violence, crime, alcohol or drug abuse. Kids of some of these dysfunctional families would wind up getting exposed to the outside world through the improved schools that sprang up there in the 1960s and 70s who left the cycle to have a normal life.

“The Banshees of Inisherin” takes place a century ago in an isolated community in Ireland. And I realized, thinking back of my father telling stories about family feuds and hate that dated back to the Civil War or Revolutionary era or my mom’s side of the family relating similar stories, that the two families carried all this trauma and way of thinking with them a couple hundred years ago when they came from Europe.

That’s the central thing that pissed me off about “Hillbilly Elegy”.

JD Vance took all the wrong lessons from his experience. He’s still the little boy, wallowing in the misery of generations of trauma, probably passed from his ancestors that lived three hundred years ago that came from isolated rural communities in Europe.

And, really, the two views of the “American Experiment” on the right and left reflect this. Liberals understand that the leaders of the Revolution came to America for a new and better life to break this cycle of ignorance, religious tradition, and infighting. Conservatives see the leaders of the Revolution as the people who escaped change in Europe to go hide themselves in corners of the New World, to wallow in the same dysfunction they always had.

That’s why JD Vance wants the same for everyone else. He has no real sense of self reflection and it’s all he understands.

Expand full comment
931 more comments...

No posts