Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Crip Dyke's avatar

I hate war and I would never commit violence myself. That said, the world is a messy place, and one does not halt war by giving conquerors what they wish. That emboldens those who start wars, and ultimately increases the spread of war. In light of that, my refusal to engage in violence even in self defense could be rationally see as wrong, or at the very least unproductive.

I don't see it that way. We must constantly struggle with the tension between harm reduction and eradication. If we are to reduce the harms of war between now and the day the last war ends, we must have people who stand up to fight against invaders and war mongers. If we are to ever see the day that the last war ends, we must have people who stand as examples of principled non-violence.

I hold myself to stringent standards of non-violence and hope that this is enough to provide a positive example to some, but I do not condemn self-defence, and respect that in this world it must be a right of individuals and nations who choose it.

For that reason, I am glad that the United States will be sending military aid to Ukraine, and triply glad that it will be sending humanitarian aid to Gaza, other parts of Palestine, and Israel.

I feel deeply conflicted over the military aid going to Israel, because I do not trust the Netanyahu government to limit itself to defense. There is a need for defense, certainly. But there is a tradition of Israeli governments, especially Netanyahu's, of exceeding the needs of defense, of disrespecting the humanity of Palestinians.

My heart is going to continue to slowly tear itself apart over what's happening in Israel, Gaza, and Palestine, and I don't know how to fix that or this war. Indeed, it is the inability to constrain the violence of war once unleashed -- even and perhaps especially when unleashed for good reason -- that makes me so resolute in never taking arms, never firing a shot, never striking a blow, no matter the cause.

Next year in Jerusalem I wish only a safe and lasting peace.

Expand full comment
ReSister For Life Callyson's avatar

If you can click on it, the photo is worth the proverbial thousand words...

ukraine

1d

For those who were upset with 🇺🇦 flags in the Congress - 🇺🇲 flags in the Verkhovna Rada (Ukrainian parliament).

We value your support, USA!

https://www.threads.net/@ukraine/post/C6HFPzXNNfJ

Expand full comment
450 more comments...

No posts